Quick verdict
If you want a new, feature-rich controller, the Sony DualSense Edge Wireless Controller is the capable pick. If you want a pad at a lower price, the Microsoft Xbox One Wireless Controller Model 1708 is the practical route. They serve different consoles, so the real question is which platform you play. The Sony model is the one to pick when you want more control options. The Microsoft model is the one to pick when you want to keep the cost down. Match the console first, then decide how much control tuning matters to you. For many shoppers, the console in your setup will settle the debate before the price does.
Price and feature comparison
| Product | Listed price | Condition | Compatibility | Notable features | Price bar |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sony DualSense Edge Wireless Controller | $145.99 | New | PlayStation 5 | Adjustable sensitivity, removable/adjustable joysticks, extra back buttons, wireless | |
| Microsoft Xbox One Wireless Controller Model 1708 | $14.99 | Used | Xbox One | Fully working per stick drift test, wireless, plastic build |
Where each controller wins
- Sony DualSense Edge wins for players who want a controller they can tune. The feature set is aimed at someone who likes to fine-tune sticks and add extra rear controls.
- Microsoft Xbox One Wireless Controller wins on listed price and simplicity. The listing includes no extra accessories, so the package stays straightforward.
- The listed price gap is $131.00. The Sony model is the higher-priced option; the Microsoft model is the lower-priced option.
Product notes
SONY - PlayStation DualSense Edge Wireless Controller - (Midnight Black) - New
The feature-forward option in this head-to-head is a controller with adjustable sensitivity, removable/adjustable joysticks, and extra back buttons. If you want to tune how the sticks respond and have additional rear buttons, this is the one to choose. The Midnight Black plastic finish keeps the look simple, and the listing describes wireless connectivity with a range of 5-10 meters. The trade-off is the listed price: at $145.99, it costs $131.00 more than the Xbox controller. The listing also includes a 1-year manufacturer warranty. That combination of adjustable controls and warranty coverage makes it a more complete package for a player who expects to customize the feel.
Fully Working Microsoft Xbox One Wireless Controller White/Black Model 1708
The lower-priced entry is a used Microsoft controller with a Model 1708 designation. The listing describes it as fully working, with stick drift test values well below the drift threshold, so it is positioned as a tested, usable pad. The white and black plastic build keeps the design simple. If you want a no-extras controller without spending as much, this is the pick. The limitations are clear: it is used, and no other accessories are included. It does not list the adjustable sensitivity, removable joysticks, or back buttons that appear on the Sony controller, so it is best for standard play. For someone who just needs a functional pad at a lower price, those limitations are easy to accept.
Final choice by use case
- Choose the Sony DualSense Edge if you are outfitting a PS5 and want a controller you can tune. It is the higher-priced entry, and it carries the extra control set.
- Choose the Microsoft Xbox One Wireless Controller if you are outfitting an Xbox One and want a straightforward pad. It is the direct pick, with no extra accessories to think about.
The $131.00 gap is really about platform and condition, so the right choice depends on which console you own and how much control tuning matters to you. If you play less often, the lower-priced pad may be all you need; if you want detailed control, the higher-priced pad may justify its cost.
